L’Affaire and Balanced
Posted in General, On This Day on October 15th, 2015 by Eugene Finerman – 2 CommentsOctober 15, 1894: France Needs a Scapegoat
On this day in 1894, Captain Alfred Dreyfus was arrested for espionage, accused of giving France’s military secrets to Germany. The charge itself seems incredible. What would the vastly superior German army learn from spying on the French. Souffle recipes? The Germans would have ruined them anyway by adding sausage and potatoes.
Dreyfus also happened to be innocent. However, the Army had reached its verdict before the court-martial, and any inconvenient contradictions–such as the evidence–were considered an insult to the image of the army. Dreyfus had to be guilty, and the facts were irrelevant. The Conservatives of the time were indignant that anyone would weight the innocence of one man (and a circumcised bourgeois at that) against the honor of the Army.
Here is the updated version of the reactionaries’ reactions:
Michael Medved: The skewed liberal perspective is missing the real story. This situation really is a compliment to the French Army. A Jew can be an officer! I am thrilled to know that. What a tribute to this country! Every Jewish boy in France can grow up to be a Captain Dreyfus!
Bill O’Reilly: What is Dreyfus’ problem? If he didn’t want to be a scapegoat, why is he Jewish? It is what these people are good at, that and violins. Talk about an easy job, for doing nothing, he is going to spend a few years at a tropical resort. You and I should be so lucky, but we have to work for a living.
Ann Coulter: Of course, Dreyfus is guilty. The army ordered him to be guilty and he refused. That is the definition of treason.
Donald Trump: You can see the pattern. Alfred, Alsace, alien, Allemagne, allied to the Ottoman Empire which worships Allah. And what kind of name is Ottoman? Otto is definitely German. So Germany and the Ottoman Empire are actually the same country, and Alfred Dreyfus is really a Moslem.